Stupid Coupon-Eligible Converter Box
Monday, April 14th, 2008CECB or Coupon-Eligible Converter Box is a specification for converter boxes eligible to receive subsidy coupons through the U.S. federally-sponsored DTV Converter Box Coupon Program. (Ref - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CECB)
I still own my old Panasonic TAU (27 inch flat screen tube SDTV) and occasionally turn it on. So buying a converter box for less than $10 was pretty exciting. So I started browsing https://www.dtv2009.gov/ and other related sites to gather more information
Though the $40 coupon looked exciting at first look, I was able to find many serious flaws in this federal sponsored program.
- $40 is not a big deal for most of US resident. We pay more than $40 to car mechanic who spend an hour fixing something. US is a rich country and guess people can easily manage to buy converter box without any federal aid. Why don’t we use the fund in better causes?
- NTIA criteria for a qualified converter box is pretty stupid. Any device which doing anything more than simply converting a digital over-the-air television signal (ATSC) is dis-qualified. Any device with modern output ports (like DVI, HDMI, VGA etc) is dis-qualified. How dumb!
Fed is investing millions of dollars in to something which is bound to turn into piece of junk in a year or two. Most of tube TV are pretty old by now and I don’t think that anyone will invest a single penny in repairing them after they turn bad or dead.
- This coupon program creates a big completion to dis-qualified but technically up-to-date converter boxes and DVRs. It is sad that now a future-proof box (with QAM, HDMI, DVI) priced at $70 competes with CECB $10 (would be $50 otherwise).
I think this program goes very opposite to Hybrid tax credit and effectively pushing people to stay on old technology. It is not expensive to include those modern features into converter box but Fed killed it.
If I can buy a QAM capable device (with this coupon), I may not need a second set-top-box from Comcast (at the expense of scrambled channels) and still use this device for many years. If I can buy a DVR (with this coupon), I can do a lot and stay up-to-date on technology. I feel that it would be definitely a better use of this coupon money.
(more…)

